During last week’s comment war regarding money, I noticed some limitations with blogging that I would like to discuss. Does anybody feel that the current model for commenting on blog posts is limited? Let me try to spell out what’s in my imagination, and maybe we can see where that gets us.
Ok so I wrote that super long comment, and maybe some people read it (hopefully), but because it was so long, it made it difficult to comment on. What would be nice would be to have a way to open up discussion on one small point, that could expand and contract at the particular point in the article. That way, comments on particular points are localized to that point in the article.
Then, it would be nice to expand that kind of functionality in a global sense. How many times have we said, “This has already been discussed elsewhere on the web.” ? It would be cool to have a metablogging platform, where each post on all the individual blogs on the internet are tagged for content, and then some kind of software would encompass the totality of blogs out there. It is important to remember that each individual blog contributes something unique. So combining these ideas we get some kind of system that organizes blogs by topics (not just a list) and then when particular blogs post about particular topics, they are placed into that topic. In this way, a blog like McCrappy could review the discussion that already happened “elsewhere on the web,” and then our unique additions to the topic could be placed into that one larger context.
So you could have a topic like “The History of Money”, and then you get a list of all blogs that discussed that topic. The blog with the most hits on that particular topic would be listed first. Then you could expand discussions that particular blogs added to that topic. So, under the “The History of Money,” there would be, say, a plus sign with the word “McCrappy” next to it, and in that way, people could see what McCrappy had to say on this subject, as well as other active blogs.
It would be really cool to have a way to visually explore the blogosphere. So again you could type in “money” and then see a couple of “hotspots” in a 3D space where recent activity on that topic would be highlighted. You can then go to the hotspot and see a list of active blogs discussing it, and you can see the posts. Kind of a way to visually navigate similar discussions all over the web. As long as each discussion was tagged for content, this would be achievable by searching the tagspace.
Additionally, you could view the branching in the 3D space, so you could see similar discussion topics occurring (i.e., the “financial breakdown” would be close to “history of money” in that space). Or let’s say comments on a particular post lead to a divergent thought, well at that point you would see a branching away from the main line of thought. And that divergent line would converge to another topic. In this way, you could visually navigate discussions from multiple blogs as they converged and diverged, similarly to how wikipedia allows you to surf topic after topic.
I don’t think anybody is doing anything like this…
Recent Comments